React Native vs Cordova: Choosing the Right Mobile Framework

In the fast-paced world of mobile development, choosing the right framework can make all the difference. React Native and Cordova are two popular options, each with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. In this tutorial, we will compare React Native and Cordova in terms of performance, development experience, native capabilities, community and ecosystem, and maintenance and updates. By the end of this tutorial, you will have a clear understanding of which framework is best suited for your mobile development needs.

react native vs cordova choosing right mobile framework

What is React Native?

React Native is a JavaScript framework developed by Facebook for building native mobile applications. It allows developers to write code once and deploy it on both iOS and Android platforms. React Native uses native components, which makes the apps look and feel like native applications. It also provides access to platform-specific APIs, allowing developers to incorporate device features seamlessly into their apps.

What is Cordova?

Cordova, previously known as PhoneGap, is an open-source mobile development framework. It enables developers to build mobile apps using HTML, CSS, and JavaScript. Cordova wraps the app code in a WebView, which is essentially a browser window without the browser chrome. This allows the app to run on multiple platforms with a single codebase. Cordova provides access to device features through plugins, which are packages that interface with native APIs.

Performance

Speed

When it comes to speed, React Native has the advantage. React Native apps are compiled into native code, which allows them to run faster than Cordova apps. The performance difference is especially noticeable when it comes to animations and transitions, where React Native excels.

To demonstrate the speed of React Native, let's create a simple app that displays a list of items. We will use the FlatList component from React Native, which is optimized for displaying large lists efficiently.

Here's the code for the React Native app:

import React from 'react';
import { View, FlatList, Text } from 'react-native';

const data = [
  { id: 1, title: 'Item 1' },
  { id: 2, title: 'Item 2' },
  { id: 3, title: 'Item 3' },
  // Add more items...
];

const App = () => {
  return (
    <View>
      <FlatList
        data={data}
        keyExtractor={(item) => item.id.toString()}
        renderItem={({ item }) => <Text>{item.title}</Text>}
      />
    </View>
  );
};

export default App;

The above code creates a simple React Native app that displays a list of items. The FlatList component efficiently renders the list and updates it when necessary. This results in a smooth and responsive user experience.

On the other hand, Cordova apps rely on a WebView to render the user interface, which introduces some overhead. This can lead to slower performance, especially when dealing with large lists or complex UI interactions.

Memory Usage

In terms of memory usage, React Native also has the upper hand. React Native apps consume less memory compared to Cordova apps. This is because React Native directly interacts with native components, whereas Cordova apps rely on the WebView, which adds an additional layer of memory consumption.

To illustrate the memory usage advantage of React Native, let's consider the same list app example as before. We will use the FlatList component from React Native and the ons-list component from Cordova.

Here's the code for the Cordova app:

<!DOCTYPE html>
<html>
<head>
  <title>List App</title>
  <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="css/index.css">
  <script type="text/javascript" src="js/index.js"></script>
</head>
<body>
  <ons-list>
    <ons-list-item>Item 1</ons-list-item>
    <ons-list-item>Item 2</ons-list-item>
    <ons-list-item>Item 3</ons-list-item>
    <!-- Add more items... -->
  </ons-list>
</body>
</html>

The above code creates a simple Cordova app that displays a list of items using the ons-list component. The app relies on a WebView to render the UI, which consumes more memory compared to the React Native approach.

UI Responsiveness

React Native also shines in terms of UI responsiveness. React Native apps have a more native-like feel, with smooth animations and responsive user interactions. This is because React Native leverages the device's GPU to render UI components, resulting in a snappier user experience.

On the other hand, Cordova apps may suffer from UI lag and slower response times, especially when dealing with complex UI interactions or resource-intensive operations. This is due to the additional layer introduced by the WebView, which can affect the app's overall responsiveness.

Development Experience

Language and Framework

React Native and Cordova differ in terms of the language and framework used for development. React Native uses JavaScript and the React framework, which is widely adopted and has a large developer community. This makes it easier to find resources, tutorials, and support when working with React Native.

On the other hand, Cordova uses HTML, CSS, and JavaScript for development. While these technologies are familiar to web developers, they may not be as performant or optimized for mobile development compared to React Native's JavaScript and React framework.

Tooling

When it comes to tooling, React Native offers a more streamlined and modern development experience. React Native comes with a command-line interface (CLI) that provides tools for creating, building, and testing apps. It also has a rich ecosystem of third-party libraries and tools that enhance the development process.

Cordova, on the other hand, relies on plugins for accessing device features and extending functionality. While plugins provide flexibility, they can also introduce complexity and dependency management challenges. Cordova also lacks a unified CLI, which can make the development process less straightforward compared to React Native.

Hot Reloading

Hot reloading is a feature that allows developers to see the impact of code changes in real-time without having to manually reload the app. React Native has built-in support for hot reloading, which significantly speeds up the development process. With hot reloading, developers can make code changes and immediately see the effects without losing the app's state.

On the other hand, Cordova does not have built-in support for hot reloading. Developers need to manually reload the app each time they make code changes, which can slow down the development process and disrupt the workflow.

Native Capabilities

Access to Device Features

When it comes to accessing device features, React Native has a clear advantage. React Native provides a rich set of pre-built components that map directly to native UI components. This allows developers to easily access and utilize device features such as cameras, GPS, sensors, and more.

Cordova, on the other hand, relies on plugins to access device features. While there is a wide range of plugins available, they may not always provide the same level of integration and performance as React Native's native components.

Integration with Native Code

React Native provides the ability to integrate with existing native code, which can be useful when developing complex applications or when there is a need to access platform-specific APIs. React Native achieves this through its native module system, which allows developers to write custom native code and bridge it with JavaScript.

Cordova also allows integration with native code through plugins. However, Cordova plugins are typically written in JavaScript and rely on WebView communication to interact with native APIs. This can introduce performance overhead and may not provide the same level of flexibility as React Native's native module system.

Community and Ecosystem

Popularity

In terms of popularity, React Native enjoys a larger developer community compared to Cordova. React Native has gained significant traction since its introduction and is widely adopted by developers worldwide. This popularity translates into a larger pool of resources, tutorials, and community support.

Cordova, while still popular, has seen a decline in popularity in recent years. This can make it harder to find up-to-date resources and community support compared to React Native.

Third-Party Libraries

Both React Native and Cordova have a rich ecosystem of third-party libraries and tools to enhance the development process. React Native's popularity has resulted in a larger number of libraries, which cover a wide range of functionalities, including UI components, navigation, state management, and more.

Cordova also has a significant number of plugins available, which provide access to various device features and extend the functionality of the app. However, the number of Cordova plugins may be smaller compared to React Native libraries.

Community Support

React Native's large developer community translates into strong community support. Developers can find answers to their questions, participate in discussions, and receive assistance from the community. This can significantly speed up the development process and help overcome challenges.

Cordova also has an active community, albeit smaller compared to React Native. While there may be fewer resources and discussions available, developers can still find support and guidance from the Cordova community.

Maintenance and Updates

Long-Term Support

React Native benefits from the backing of Facebook, which provides long-term support and regular updates to the framework. This ensures that React Native stays up-to-date with the latest mobile technologies and platform changes. It also means that developers can rely on a stable and well-maintained framework for their mobile development needs.

Cordova, on the other hand, is an open-source project that relies on community contributions for maintenance and updates. While the Cordova community is active, the level of support and updates may vary depending on community involvement. This can introduce challenges when it comes to keeping the app up-to-date with the latest platform changes.

Compatibility with Future OS Versions

React Native's close integration with native components and APIs ensures better compatibility with future OS versions. React Native apps are less likely to experience compatibility issues when new OS versions are released.

Cordova, on the other hand, relies on WebView communication and plugin dependencies, which may introduce compatibility issues with future OS versions. Developers may need to rely on plugin updates or make modifications to their code to ensure compatibility.

Conclusion

In conclusion, choosing the right mobile framework depends on your specific requirements and priorities. React Native offers better performance, a more modern development experience, and easier access to native capabilities. It also benefits from a larger community and better long-term support.

On the other hand, Cordova can be a good choice if you prefer web technologies for development, have an existing codebase in HTML, CSS, and JavaScript, or require access to specific Cordova plugins.

Ultimately, it's important to evaluate your project's requirements, consider the trade-offs, and choose the framework that best aligns with your development goals.